Good news and ..... Or the continuing saga of Caroline the cat

I got home relatively early tonight, and decided that I should really take the cat to the vet to make sure that her diet is working. As soon as I got out the leash the cat was off like a bolt of lightning, even though her supper was waiting in her dish. It took three of us to get her out from under the bed, tucked into her leash -- which she managed to wiggle out of the first time I tried to put it on -- a big hint that she has lost weight.

Now for the bad news -- at least from my end -- or maybe from hers. When I took her from my husband to take her out to the car she peed on me -- G-d cat urine stinks. So now I have a crying cat in my arms, her back claws are sticking out as far as they will go, and the front of my leg is wet and smelly. I figured nothing worse could happen -- the vet is really only seven minutes away -- so we went. Nothing worse did happen, fortunately, and we got in and out of the vets quickly, but now for the good news, I hope.

Caroline was 17lbs when we took her to the vet this summer. This evening she weighed 14.5, so she lost about 15% of her body weight. That means kitty Atkins is working. My husband's question is, is it working too well. Is she in fact losing weight too fast, and how much weight is enough. What is an ideal weight for my little cat. Could she, in fact, be malnourished? Hopefully the vet will call tomorrow with answers to all my questions!